Files
crewAI/lib
Lucas Gomide 16bd159eab refactor(otel): unify LLM event introspection + drop redundant defensive code
Three cohesion cleanups uncovered during PR review, all behavior-preserving:

- LLM.call / LLM.acall in llm.py now delegate to BaseLLM._emit_call_started_event
  instead of constructing LLMCallStartedEvent inline. The base helper already
  introspects sampling params off self via getattr; the inline duplication was
  accidental, not justified, and a duplication risk if anyone adds a tenth
  OTel sampling param later.

- Extracted lib/crewai/llms/_finish_reason_utils.py:extract_choices_finish_reason_and_id
  as the shared extractor for the choices-based response shape. OpenAI Chat,
  Azure, and LiteLLM all read the same shape (response.id + choices[0].finish_reason)
  as both object attrs and dict keys. Providers with genuinely different shapes
  - Anthropic (stop_reason), Bedrock (stopReason), Gemini (protobuf enum),
  OpenAI Responses (status) - keep their own provider-specific helpers.

- Dropped redundant try/except (AttributeError, TypeError) wrappers around
  bare getattr(obj, "field", None) calls across the new extraction helpers.
  getattr with a default already suppresses AttributeError, and the inner
  isinstance / dict.get / int-coercion ops can't raise TypeError in practice.
  Kept the catches that legitimately guard against IndexError (e.g. choices[0]
  on an empty list).

Tests: 600 passed, 23 skipped, 14 pre-existing multimodal failures unchanged.
Added 12 parametrized tests for the shared helper covering object + dict
shapes, missing fields, non-string coercion, and never-raises invariants.
2026-05-27 18:12:37 -03:00
..