fix(tools): sandbox FileWriterTool writes and fix file tool rough edges (#6692)
Some checks failed
CodeQL Advanced / Analyze (actions) (push) Has been cancelled
CodeQL Advanced / Analyze (python) (push) Has been cancelled
Check Documentation Broken Links / Check broken links (push) Has been cancelled
Vulnerability Scan / pip-audit (push) Has been cancelled

* fix(tools): sandbox FileWriterTool writes and fix file tool rough edges

FileReadTool confined reads to the working directory, but FileWriterTool
only checked that `filename` stayed inside `directory` — and `directory`
itself is an LLM-supplied schema field. An agent could therefore write
anywhere the process had permission to, including ~/.ssh and site-packages,
while the reader refused to read back what the writer had just written.
FileWriterTool was the only filesystem tool in the package that did not go
through validate_file_path; files_compressor_tool validates even its
output path.

Writes are now confined to base_dir (the working directory by default):
the resolved directory must sit inside base_dir, and the resolved file
must sit inside that directory. The pre-existing filename containment
check is kept as-is and still applies even when the unsafe-paths escape
hatch is on, so no existing guarantee is weakened.

Both tools gain a base_dir field so a developer can widen the sandbox
deliberately instead of reaching for the process-wide
CREWAI_TOOLS_ALLOW_UNSAFE_PATHS kill switch. FileReadTool also stops
rejecting a file_path given to its own constructor: that is
developer-declared intent, and declaring one file does not expose its
siblings.

Also fixed:

- FileReadTool scanned the whole file when reading a line window; it now
  stops via islice once the requested lines are collected.
- FileWriterTool._run(**kwargs) made the documented positional call
  signature raise TypeError and turned a missing overwrite into
  "error accessing key". It now takes named parameters in the documented
  (filename, content, directory) order.
- A directory naming an existing file reported "already exists and
  overwrite option was not passed" even with overwrite=True; it now
  explains the real problem.
- Subdirectories inside filename are created, matching what passing
  directory already did.
- Both tools now write and decode UTF-8 by default instead of the
  platform locale encoding, with an encoding field to override. The docs
  already claimed UTF-8 and recommended the writer to Windows users.
- The writer's schema fields had no descriptions for the LLM.
- Docs claimed FileReadTool parses JSON into a dict (it never has),
  shipped a snippet that raised TypeError, and did not mention the path
  sandbox. The writer README also began with a stray "Here's the
  rewritten README" preamble.

BREAKING CHANGE: FileWriterTool no longer writes outside the working
directory. Pass base_dir to authorize a different tree.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* chore: update tool specifications

* fix(tools): make the declared FileReadTool file reachable by agents

Addresses review feedback on #6692.

The constructor-path exemption did not actually work the way an agent
calls the tool. The description only advertises a redacted label (the
basename, when the file sits outside the sandbox), but resolution
required the exact absolute path, so the model's call was sandboxed and
the declared file was never read. Worse, file_path was a required schema
field, so the long-documented "call with no arguments to read the default
file" raised a validation error instead:

    FileReadTool(file_path="/outside/declared.txt")
    .run()                          -> ValueError: validation failed
    .run(file_path="declared.txt")  -> Error: File not found
    .run(file_path="/outside/declared.txt") -> works, but the model was
                                               never told this path

file_path is now optional in the schema, so omitting it reads the default,
and the declared file is addressable by the label the description shows
the model as well as by its real path. Declaring one file still does not
expose its siblings.

The declared path is also pinned to its real path at construction, so a
later chdir cannot silently repoint it at a different file — previously a
relative constructor path re-resolved against the new working directory
on every call.

Also guards the writer's filepath resolution, which could raise
ValueError out of _run for a filename containing a null byte, breaking
the contract of always returning a descriptive string. The directory and
read paths were already guarded.

Adds docstrings to strtobool and both _run methods, corrects an Arabic
tanween spelling and a kaf-as-descriptor calque in the localized read
docs, and regenerates tool.specs.json for the schema change.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(tools): anchor the declared read path to base_dir, not the cwd

Addresses the second round of review feedback on #6692.

The previous commit pinned a relative constructor file_path with
os.path.realpath, which anchors to the working directory, while both
format_path_for_display and validate_file_path anchor a relative path to
base_dir. With the two roots disagreeing, the same relative string meant
two different files — and the tool served the cwd one under a label that
looks like it belongs to the sandbox:

    FileReadTool(file_path="data.txt", base_dir="/allowed")   # cwd=/work
    label advertised to the model -> "data.txt"
    run(file_path="data.txt")     -> contents of /work/data.txt

That reads a file from outside base_dir, so it was a sandbox escape
introduced by the exemption itself, not just a wrong-file bug.

Resolution now goes through a single _resolve_against_base helper that
anchors relative paths exactly the way the sandbox does, so the pinned
path, the advertised label and the containment check all agree. Covered
by test_relative_declared_path_anchors_to_base_dir.

Also softens "always readable" to "always allowed past the containment
check" in the docstring, README and docs, since bypassing containment
does not guarantee the read succeeds — it can still fail on a missing
file, a directory, or permissions.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(tools): tell the LLM about the path sandbox in tool descriptions

Addresses the low-confidence notes from the Copilot review on #6692.

Both tools' descriptions were pre-sandbox wording, so the model learned
about containment only by attempting a path and reading the error back.
Both now state that access is confined to the tool's allowed directory
and that a path resolving outside it is rejected.

The wording deliberately says "the tool's allowed directory" rather than
"the working directory", because the root is base_dir when one is set,
and naming the absolute root would leak it into the prompt — the same
reason paths are redacted in errors.

Not changed: the notes also suggested advertising `encoding`. That is a
constructor-only field the model cannot set, so describing it to the LLM
would be misleading.

Also fixes a test docstring that contradicted its own assertion — the
public run() path does raise on schema validation failure, which is what
the test asserts.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(tools): anchor base_dir at construction so the sandbox cannot move

Addresses the third review round on #6692.

Both remaining findings came from the same habit: storing an unanchored
string and re-resolving it later.

A relative base_dir was kept verbatim and re-resolved against getcwd() on
every call, while the declared file was pinned once at construction. After
a chdir the sandbox root moved but the declared default did not, so one
tool applied two different roots. base_dir is now resolved once — in the
reader's __init__, and via a field_validator on the writer so it also
applies on the model_validate path.

That also covers the serialization concern. model_dump drops the private
pin, and __init__ re-runs on restore, so a relative file_path was
re-anchored against whatever the working directory happened to be at load
time. With base_dir anchored, restore rebuilds the identical pin.

The residual case is a relative file_path with no base_dir, where the
sandbox root is the working directory too — so both move together and the
tool stays self-consistent. Covered by
test_declared_path_survives_a_serialization_round_trip and
test_relative_base_dir_is_anchored_at_construction on both tools.

Also corrects the writer's 'directory' description, README and docs: the
default resolves inside the tool's allowed directory, which is base_dir
when one is set, not always the working directory.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: github-actions[bot] <41898282+github-actions[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
This commit is contained in:
João Moura
2026-07-28 06:20:26 -03:00
committed by GitHub
parent 97981ed31b
commit 2e95bfb4e8
17 changed files with 1017 additions and 111 deletions

View File

@@ -11,10 +11,12 @@ mode: "wide"
We are still working on improving tools, so there might be unexpected behavior or changes in the future.
</Note>
The FileReadTool conceptually represents a suite of functionalities within the crewai_tools package aimed at facilitating file reading and content retrieval.
This suite includes tools for processing batch text files, reading runtime configuration files, and importing data for analytics.
It supports a variety of text-based file formats such as `.txt`, `.csv`, `.json`, and more. Depending on the file type, the suite offers specialized functionality,
such as converting JSON content into a Python dictionary for ease of use.
The `FileReadTool` reads the contents of a file from the local file system and returns it as text.
It is useful for batch text file processing, reading runtime configuration files, and importing data for analytics.
It supports any text-based file format, such as `.txt`, `.csv`, `.json`, and `.md`.
Content is always returned as plain text — parsing it (for example, `json.loads` on a `.json` file) is up to the agent or your own code.
For large files, `start_line` and `line_count` read just a window of lines instead of loading the whole file.
## Installation
@@ -31,15 +33,48 @@ To get started with the FileReadTool:
```python Code
from crewai_tools import FileReadTool
# Initialize the tool to read any files the agents knows or lean the path for
# Initialize the tool to read any file the agent knows or learns the path for
file_read_tool = FileReadTool()
# OR
# Initialize the tool with a specific file path, so the agent can only read the content of the specified file
# Initialize with a specific file path, so the agent reads that file by default
file_read_tool = FileReadTool(file_path='path/to/your/file.txt')
# Read a window of lines (lines 100-149) instead of the whole file
partial_content = file_read_tool.run(
file_path='path/to/your/file.txt',
start_line=100,
line_count=50,
)
```
## Arguments
- `file_path`: The path to the file you want to read. It accepts both absolute and relative paths. Ensure the file exists and you have the necessary permissions to access it.
The agent supplies these at runtime:
- `file_path`: (Optional) The path to the file you want to read. Accepts absolute and relative paths. Ensure the file exists and you have the necessary permissions to access it. Omit it to read the default file configured at construction; if there is no default, the tool reports that no path was provided.
- `start_line`: (Optional) The line number to start reading from (1-indexed). Defaults to `1`.
- `line_count`: (Optional) The number of lines to read. If omitted, reads from `start_line` to the end of the file.
You set these when constructing the tool:
- `file_path`: (Optional) A default file to read when the agent calls the tool with no arguments.
- `base_dir`: (Optional) The directory that runtime paths must stay inside. Defaults to the current working directory.
- `encoding`: (Optional) Text encoding used to decode the file. Defaults to `utf-8`.
## Allowed paths
Because the file path is usually chosen by an LLM at runtime, reads are confined to a sandbox:
- Paths supplied at runtime must resolve inside `base_dir`, which defaults to the current working directory. `..` segments and symlinks are resolved before the check, so they cannot be used to escape.
- A `file_path` passed to the constructor is developer-declared intent, so it is always allowed past the containment check — even outside `base_dir`. The read itself can still fail if the file is missing, is a directory, or is not permitted. It is pinned when the tool is built, so a later change of working directory cannot repoint it, and the agent can address it either by omitting `file_path` or by using the name shown in the tool's description. Declaring one file does not expose its siblings.
To let an agent read a directory tree outside the working directory, point `base_dir` at it:
```python Code
# The agent may read anything under /data, and nothing outside it
file_read_tool = FileReadTool(base_dir='/data')
```
As a last resort, setting `CREWAI_TOOLS_ALLOW_UNSAFE_PATHS=true` disables path validation. This applies process-wide to every crewai-tools tool, including the SSRF protections on URL-fetching tools, so prefer `base_dir`.